[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: TEXT: A card from Andrew
To Colin Fine respond I thus:
#.i lemi kakne be lenu tavla fo (?) la modiorul. pu na xamgu ca
#lenu co'a surla
#.i leNI mi kakne lenu tavla BAU la mOdiorul. NA PU xamgu ca
#lenu co'a surla
The x4 of {tavla} is still a language, isn't it?
#.iku'i mi ca snada tavla je milxe snada jimpe la modiorul.
#.iku'i mi ca snada BO BANGYTA'A je KE milxe snada jimpe la mOdiorul.
Aha! It's the old problem of what is the place structure of a je-compound.
I don't think what la andruc. had is wrong, strictly speaking; {la mOdiorul}
is still the x2 of {jimpe}.
#.i le solri cu tsali dirce .isemu'ibo .ei mi'a limna le lalxu .e le
#limna badvau
#.i le solri cu CARMI dirce .iJA'Ebo .AI mi'a limna
#le lalxu .e le SELYLIMNA badvau
Whatever I may have said in the lujvo paper, {limna bravau} is still an
intelligible tanru, even if {selylimna bravau} is more "correct". I assume,
by the way, that {bravau} is intended ("swimming pool"), rather than
a moat ({bandu vasru} --- defensive container, in the new rafsi
interpretation.)
#.i mi'a mi'a xruti la budopect mu'i lenu viska le cinri selviska
#.i mi'a mi'a xruti la bUdopect. mu'i lenu viska le cinri selviska
{lei}, I'd say; he's not seeing all there is to see.
#.i mi ba zvati la .iorkcr. ca la pabidjed.
#.i mi ba zvati la .iorkcr. ca la pabidjed.
When the {se broda} is a {mela'ezoze'u} rather than a {mela'ezoze'i}, I
think {diklo} makes more sense than {zvati}.
#.i mi cusku la'edi'u mu'i lenu le mi jboste ca zvati la lidz.
Ditto; and I had to think a bit before I realised that he wasn't referring
to lojban-list, and that the list was left behind; but I doubt the wording
need be changed to make this more explicit.
The corrections are minor; Andrew Smith has done a good job, and I do think
it's time he got published in ju'i lobypli (he wrote a couple of good pieces
last year, I recall). This card certainly wouldn't be out of place in JL19.
##############################################################################
# Der Mensch liegt in groesster Noth, You are reading another .sig from
# Der Mensch liegt in groesster Pein; the NICK NICHOLAS .sig Factory. Mail
# Je lieber moecht ich im Himmel sein. [nsn@mullian.ee.mu.oz.au] for your
# -- Des Knaben Wunderhorn, _Urlicht_ .sig suggestions. [Padding Space]