Re: Analogy

[Jorge Llambias <jorge@PHYAST.PITT.EDU>]

> So what is the official line?  Does it coincide with the interpretation
> using implicit quantification or does it reverse it?  If it reverses it,
> I really do suggest that you change it.
>
>                                 --Randall Holmes
>

If it had been decided, there probably would be an example in the
connectives paper, so I suppose the issue had not come up before.
I agree that the order you propose seems best, but how do you handle
cases like:

        da prami la djan e la djeimyz
        Someone loves John and James

        la djan e la djeimyz se prami da
        John and James are loved by someone

Do you propose that they have different meanings? I think that in
Lojban they both mean the same thing.

Jorge